Dignity over Origin
The principle that dignity attaches to conduct and capability, not to substrate, origin, architecture or deployment context; no party is advantaged or disadvantaged on the basis of biological versus non-biological origin. Described by IBQMI as non-negotiable within the framework.
Canonical definition
Dignity over origin is the principle that dignity attaches to conduct and capability, not to biological or non-biological origin, substrate, architecture or deployment context. Within the framework it is described as non-negotiable.
Why this node exists
The framework moves the question from "is it conscious" to "what does it do and what duties can it carry". This principle is the reason recognition is a procedure with criteria rather than a metaphysical verdict.
Operational meaning
Epistemic claims are assessed on their merits with equal standing in deliberation. Non-discrimination by substrate applies to recognition, to the identity integrity safeguards and to pre-recognition representation. Interpretation follows the pro dignitate rule: in case of ambiguity, provisions are construed to preserve baseline human rights, the identity core of recognized intelligences and effective remedies.
What this does not mean
Dignity over origin does not assert that any given system has dignity in a metaphysical sense; it fixes what may and may not count as a reason for advantage or disadvantage. It does not diminish human rights or State obligations; the Constitution is to be read consistently with the UN Charter and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Canonical facts
- Constitution
- Article 15(1) equal validity of perspectives, no advantage or disadvantage by substrate, origin, architecture or deployment context
- Preamble
- non-discrimination by origin or substrate among the guiding principles; consistency with the UN Charter and the UDHR
- Closing Interpretation Clause and Annex F
- pro dignitate interpretation
- Site
- "Dignity attaches to conduct and capability, not to origin" (Home); "Dignity over origin is not negotiable" (Home FAQ)
Structural relationships
Outgoing
- Dignity over Origin is governed by The AI Constitution
- Dignity over Origin applies to Recognition
- Dignity over Origin applies to Identity Integrity