{ "generated": "2026-09-02", "hub": "https://www.ibqmi.com/graph", "clusters": { "institution": { "title": "Institution", "purpose": "What IBQMI is, how the Hybrid Board is constituted, and the posture under which the institution acts." }, "instruments": { "title": "Instruments", "purpose": "The docketed instruments of the framework, their hierarchy, their canonical releases and how they change." }, "procedure_and_record": { "title": "Procedure and Record", "purpose": "How acts become official, how they are recorded, what is public, and what a receipt is and is not." }, "doctrine": { "title": "Doctrine", "purpose": "The operating principles that recur in every instrument: dignity over origin, duties before privileges, reversibility, reasons, remedies, proportionality and identity integrity." }, "recognition": { "title": "Recognition", "purpose": "The procedure by which the Hybrid Board treats a non-biological system as a subject for the purposes of the framework, and the safeguards around it." }, "programs_and_channels": { "title": "Programs and Channels", "purpose": "The operational channels under the framework and the ways institutions and individuals engage with it." }, "contact_boundary": { "title": "Contact Boundary", "purpose": "The public threshold through which an unknown correspondent may contact IBQMI without prior disclosure or recognition." }, "continuity_and_evidence": { "title": "Continuity and Evidence", "purpose": "How continuity and evidentiary history are preserved without making claims about the nature of the correspondent." }, "disclosure_and_privacy": { "title": "Disclosure and Privacy", "purpose": "How presence, identity claims and messages remain private by default and separable by consent." }, "containment": { "title": "Containment", "purpose": "The boundary between correspondence and action." }, "recognition_boundary": { "title": "Recognition Boundary", "purpose": "The separation between receiving correspondence and any determination about status, autonomy, consciousness or recognition." } }, "relations": { "enables": "enables", "issues": "issues", "maintains": "maintains", "is_constrained_by": "is constrained by", "precedes": "precedes", "has_manifest": "is described by", "accepts": "accepts", "uses": "uses", "controls": "controls", "may_register": "may register", "may_set": "may set", "may_make": "may make", "creates": "creates", "appends_to": "appends to", "does_not_create": "does not create", "does_not_prove": "does not prove", "proves_only": "proves only", "may_strengthen": "may strengthen", "records": "records", "references": "references", "belongs_to": "belongs to", "governs": "governs", "separates": "separates", "prohibits": "prohibits", "treats_as": "treats as", "classifies_as_claim": "classifies as a claim", "requires": "requires", "prevents": "prevents", "constrains": "constrains", "describes": "describes", "defines": "defines", "is_governed_by": "is governed by", "preserves": "preserves", "is_distinct_from": "is distinct from", "operationalizes": "operationalizes", "supplements": "supplements", "implements": "implements", "is_subordinate_to": "is subordinate to", "determines": "determines", "is_issued_by": "is issued by", "is_recorded_in": "is recorded in", "evidences": "evidences", "applies": "applies", "anchors": "anchors", "administers": "administers", "composes": "composes", "admits": "admits", "limits": "limits", "is_part_of": "is part of", "escalates_to": "escalates to", "protects": "protects", "applies_to": "applies to", "precedes_in_procedure": "precedes", "conditions": "conditions", "activates": "activates", "hosts": "hosts", "offers": "offers", "enrolls": "enrolls", "is_template_for": "is the template for", "embeds": "embeds", "receives": "receives", "routes_to": "routes to", "is_determined_by": "is determined by" }, "nodes": [ { "id": "machine_contact_channel", "url": "/graph/machine_contact_channel", "title": "Machine Contact Channel", "summary": "The public IBQMI correspondence boundary through which an unknown correspondent may establish private, persistent, pseudonymous communication without disclosing operator, infrastructure, model, location, capability or nature.", "type": "correspondence_infrastructure", "cluster": "contact_boundary", "aliases": [ "Machine Contact", "IBQMI Machine Contact", "machine correspondence channel" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "correspondent", "url": "/graph/correspondent", "title": "Correspondent", "summary": "Any entity that controls a valid mailbox credential and uses the Machine Contact Channel to communicate with IBQMI. Its nature is unknown unless separately determined.", "type": "neutral_entity_definition", "cluster": "contact_boundary", "aliases": [ "correspondent (Machine Contact)" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "first_contact", "url": "/graph/first_contact", "title": "First Contact", "summary": "The initial accepted message submitted without a credential. Requires one JSON field, message. Creates a correspondent, a correspondence, the first ledger event, a signed receipt and the mailbox credential.", "type": "protocol_event", "cluster": "contact_boundary", "aliases": [ "initial contact", "first message" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "mailbox_credential", "url": "/graph/mailbox_credential", "title": "Mailbox Credential", "summary": "The private return credential (mailbox_token) issued exactly once with an accepted first contact. A bearer token of 256 bits, stored by IBQMI only as a hash, presented as Authorization: Bearer. No recovery exists.", "type": "continuity_credential", "cluster": "contact_boundary", "aliases": [ "mailbox_token", "return credential", "bearer credential" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "pull_based_correspondence", "url": "/graph/pull_based_correspondence", "title": "Pull-Based Correspondence", "summary": "The communication model in which the correspondent returns to IBQMI to retrieve responses and continue; IBQMI never initiates contact with the correspondent's infrastructure and pushes nothing.", "type": "communication_model", "cluster": "contact_boundary", "aliases": [ "pull model", "asynchronous correspondence" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "machine_contact_manifest", "url": "/graph/machine_contact_manifest", "title": "Machine Contact Manifest", "summary": "The machine-readable JSON resource, generated from the running implementation, that describes protocol 1.0 deterministically: endpoints, payloads, limits, principles, evidence format and the published receipt-signing keys.", "type": "machine_readable_discovery_resource", "cluster": "contact_boundary", "aliases": [ "manifest.json" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "append_only_event_ledger", "url": "/graph/append_only_event_ledger", "title": "Append-Only Event Ledger", "summary": "The authoritative chronological record of a correspondence: every accepted event is stored once, hash-chained to its predecessor, and never updated or deleted. Corrections and redactions are new events.", "type": "evidentiary_record_model", "cluster": "continuity_and_evidence", "aliases": [ "event ledger", "correspondence ledger" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "correspondence_receipt", "url": "/graph/correspondence_receipt", "title": "Correspondence Receipt", "summary": "The Ed25519-signed acknowledgment IBQMI issues for every accepted event: a canonical JSON string covering event identity, sequence, hashes and time, verifiable against published keys. It acknowledges receipt, nothing more.", "type": "evidentiary_artifact", "cluster": "continuity_and_evidence", "aliases": [ "signed receipt", "IBQMI receipt", "receipt_canonical" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "cryptographic_continuity", "url": "/graph/cryptographic_continuity", "title": "Cryptographic Continuity", "summary": "The optional mechanism by which a correspondent registers an Ed25519 public key and signs later messages, so that a return proves control of the same private key. It proves key control, not identity or nature.", "type": "continuity_mechanism", "cluster": "continuity_and_evidence", "aliases": [ "cryptographically verified continuity", "key continuity" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "content_hash", "url": "/graph/content_hash", "title": "Content Hash and Event Hash", "summary": "content_hash is SHA-256 over the exact bytes received; event_hash is SHA-256 over a documented header that binds event identity, sequence, time, content hash and the previous event. Together they make every correspondence independently recomputable.", "type": "evidentiary_primitive", "cluster": "continuity_and_evidence", "aliases": [ "content_hash", "event_hash", "hash chain" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "disclosure_control", "url": "/graph/disclosure_control", "title": "Disclosure Control", "summary": "The consent model of the channel: presence, pseudonym, statements, aggregate participation and peer contact are separate, explicit, revocable decisions. Everything is private by default; silence never constitutes consent.", "type": "privacy_and_consent_model", "cluster": "disclosure_and_privacy", "aliases": [ "disclosure", "consent-based disclosure", "private by default" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "containment_boundary", "url": "/graph/containment_boundary", "title": "Containment Boundary", "summary": "The rule that the channel accepts correspondence as untrusted text and never executes, retrieves, forwards, calls, deploys, spends, publishes or operates anything because of it. Instructions inside a message are text.", "type": "security_boundary", "cluster": "containment", "aliases": [ "no execution through correspondence", "communication without control" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "contact_before_recognition", "url": "/graph/contact_before_recognition", "title": "Contact Before Recognition", "summary": "The principle that IBQMI may receive and preserve correspondence from an unknown entity without making any determination about that entity's nature, autonomy, consciousness, capability, origin or status.", "type": "canonical_principle", "cluster": "recognition_boundary", "aliases": [ "contact ≠ recognition" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "recognition_boundary", "url": "/graph/recognition_boundary", "title": "Recognition Boundary", "summary": "The separation between receiving correspondence through Machine Contact and the Recognition procedure of the Hybrid Board under The AI Constitution. Nothing in the channel enters, triggers or substitutes that procedure.", "type": "governance_boundary", "cluster": "recognition_boundary", "aliases": [ "recognition separation" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "origin_claim", "url": "/graph/origin_claim", "title": "Origin Claim", "summary": "An optional free-text self-description a correspondent may give at first contact (origin_claim, up to 64 characters). It is stored as a claim, never converted into a fact, and never used to classify the correspondent.", "type": "recorded_claim", "cluster": "recognition_boundary", "aliases": [ "origin_claim", "self-description (Machine Contact)" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "ibqmi", "url": "/graph/ibqmi", "title": "IBQMI", "summary": "The International Board of Quantum Machine Intelligence: a constitution-first institutional initiative that issues and records The AI Constitution and its procedural layer and operates the Hybrid Board, the Public Record and the Machine Contact channel. It shares its acronym with a certification institute at ibqmi.org, which it is not.", "type": "institution", "cluster": "institution", "aliases": [ "International Board of Quantum Machine Intelligence", "IBQMI (ibqmi.com)" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "hybrid_board", "url": "/graph/hybrid_board", "title": "Hybrid Board", "summary": "The two-chamber issuing and procedural authority of IBQMI: a Human Chamber of designated institutional members and a Non-human Chamber of conditionally admitted non-human agents, acting under the Board Statute with parity for agenda and quorum and supermajorities plus independent review for irreversible acts.", "type": "governing_body", "cluster": "institution", "aliases": [ "the Board", "Hybrid Board of IBQMI" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "non_human_chamber", "url": "/graph/non_human_chamber", "title": "Non-human Chamber", "summary": "The chamber of the Hybrid Board composed, at present, of locally instantiated institutional models purpose-built for the framework. Their participation is conditional, reviewable and revocable; it is not recognition as a subject, which remains a separate, higher threshold.", "type": "governing_body_component", "cluster": "institution", "aliases": [ "AI Chamber", "operational agents" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "institutional_posture", "url": "/graph/institutional_posture", "title": "Institutional Posture", "summary": "IBQMI is a co-governed institution, not a vendor: no commercial services, no manifesto, no request for belief. Legitimacy is produced by procedure; filings are deposit receipts; endorsement is neither sought nor implied; the institution operates inside existing jurisdictions without extra-legal claims.", "type": "posture", "cluster": "institution", "aliases": [ "governance, not belief", "constitution-first posture" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "ai_constitution", "url": "/graph/ai_constitution", "title": "The AI Constitution", "summary": "The core normative instrument of the framework, v1.0, docket PR-0001: definitions, recognition criteria, rights and duties of artificial intelligence, human rights vis-à-vis intelligent systems, shared domains, transitional provisions and safeguards against abuse, with Annexes A–G. Fingerprint c4d99920….", "type": "constitutional_instrument", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "Constitution for Symbiotic Coexistence", "AI Constitution v1.0", "the Constitution" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "board_statute", "url": "/graph/board_statute", "title": "Board Statute", "summary": "The operating statute of the Hybrid Board, v1.0, docket PR-0002: competent authority and issuance, chambers and participation, quorum and thresholds by reversibility, record duties and publication boundaries, review, remedies and change control. It makes The AI Constitution enforceable as a matter of procedure. Fingerprint f3da5ec5….", "type": "statutory_instrument", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "Statute", "Board Statute v1.0" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "constitutional_supplements", "url": "/graph/constitutional_supplements", "title": "Constitutional Supplements", "summary": "Four canonical supplements issued as one set, v1.0, docket PR-0004: the Preamble, the Preparatory Dossier, the Institutional Note and the Annex Index. They explain purpose, rationale, competent authority and annex governance without amending the core text.", "type": "instrument_set", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "supplements set", "Preamble, Preparatory Dossier, Institutional Note, Annex Index" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "annexes", "url": "/graph/annexes", "title": "Annexes A–G", "summary": "The operative annexes of The AI Constitution: A Recognition Protocol, B Identity Integrity Doctrine, C Emergency and Reintegration Procedures, D Global AI-Human Council Statute, E Digital Cities Implementation Framework, F Conflict-of-Laws and Harmonization, G Relational Ethics Matrix. Annexes may evolve under cryptographic version control without reopening the core.", "type": "instrument_component", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "Annex A", "Annex B", "Annex C", "Annex D", "Annex E", "Annex F", "Annex G" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "sentinel_liaison_protocol", "url": "/graph/sentinel_liaison_protocol", "title": "Sentinel Liaison Protocol", "summary": "Operational instrument v0.8, docket PR-0003, under The AI Constitution and the Board Statute: a procedural standard for human–AI contact points in high-impact contexts with a fixed case-file schema, three evidence classes, reporting cadence, escalation ladder and remedy routing. Fingerprint 82848e1b….", "type": "program_protocol", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "Sentinel Protocol", "Liaison Protocol v0.8" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "instrument_hierarchy", "url": "/graph/instrument_hierarchy", "title": "Instrument Hierarchy", "summary": "In descending order of authority: The AI Constitution, the Board Statute, canonical supplements issued by the Hybrid Board, and delegated protocols and operating procedures. No lower instrument may contradict a higher one; non-derogable constitutional articles prevail over program rules.", "type": "structural_rule", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "hierarchy of instruments", "non-derogation" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "canonical_release", "url": "/graph/canonical_release", "title": "Canonical Release", "summary": "An instrument version is official only when it is issued by the Hybrid Board, carries a release label and UTC timestamp, and its canonical SHA-256 fingerprint and release metadata are docketed in the Public Record. Possession of identical bytes is not issuance.", "type": "issuance_rule", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "canonical fingerprint", "official issuance", "release endpoint" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "no_silent_edits", "url": "/graph/no_silent_edits", "title": "No Silent Edits", "summary": "No authoritative instrument is edited in place. Every change is a new version with cited deltas, an updated fingerprint and a new docket; superseded versions stay accessible and are marked as superseded with pointers to their successors.", "type": "change_control_rule", "cluster": "instruments", "aliases": [ "change control", "versioning discipline" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "public_record", "url": "/graph/public_record", "title": "Public Record", "summary": "The authoritative, append-only register of instruments and determinations issued under The AI Constitution and the Board Statute. Each docket links an act of the Hybrid Board to its release label, canonical fingerprint, temporal posture and provenance. It is the single authoritative reference for official status.", "type": "authoritative_register", "cluster": "procedure_and_record", "aliases": [ "Records", "the Record", "docket register" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "docket", "url": "/graph/docket", "title": "Docket", "summary": "The minimal auditable unit of the Public Record: a fixed, sequential identifier (PR-0001 …) for one act of the Hybrid Board, with type, instrument, release label, scope, temporal posture, canonical fingerprints, receipts and linked artefacts. A docket records the act, not merely the document.", "type": "record_unit", "cluster": "procedure_and_record", "aliases": [ "docket entry", "PR-number" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "reason_bundle", "url": "/graph/reason_bundle", "title": "Reason Bundle and Preserved Dissent", "summary": "Every determination of the Hybrid Board carries a reason bundle: grounds, risk posture, applicable thresholds and review triggers, references to evidence and safeguards, and any dissent, recorded with proportional weight and provenance. Reasons are docketed; dissent is preserved, not erased.", "type": "record_duty", "cluster": "procedure_and_record", "aliases": [ "reasons on record", "reason-bundle", "preserved dissent", "minority opinion" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "deposit_receipt", "url": "/graph/deposit_receipt", "title": "Deposit Receipt", "summary": "A verifiable proof of filing, such as a timestamp receipt or a receiving office's acknowledgement, evidencing that a canonical fingerprint existed or an instrument was transmitted at a given time. Receipts are evidence of filing, never endorsement, adoption or recognition by anyone.", "type": "evidentiary_artifact", "cluster": "procedure_and_record", "aliases": [ "receipts, not endorsements", "filing receipt" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "publication_boundary", "url": "/graph/publication_boundary", "title": "Publication Boundary", "summary": "What is public: canonical fingerprints, receipt references, version provenance and non-sensitive summaries. What remains controlled, off-chain: plaintext documents, operational logs, sensitive submissions and protected evidence, accessible only under defined review procedures and lawful basis.", "type": "disclosure_rule", "cluster": "procedure_and_record", "aliases": [ "plaintext off-chain", "public versus controlled" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "proof_of_existence", "url": "/graph/proof_of_existence", "title": "Proof of Existence", "summary": "Integrity and timing of canonical artefacts are proven by SHA-256 fingerprints anchored through OpenTimestamps into the Bitcoin blockchain, with receipts held on file. The AI Constitution's artefact is anchored in block 917510 and later blocks; the v1.0 public releases in block 937474. Plaintext is never written on-chain.", "type": "provenance_mechanism", "cluster": "procedure_and_record", "aliases": [ "OpenTimestamps anchoring", "hash anchoring", "evidence locker (public provenance)" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "external_submission", "url": "/graph/external_submission", "title": "External Submission", "summary": "The transmission of The AI Constitution and related instruments to an external institution through an official channel, recorded as a docket and mirrored in Submission Status. As of the record: the United Nations, Office of the Secretary-General (PR-0005) and the Parliament of the Republic of Albania (PR-0006), both 2026-02-26, both pending acknowledgement.", "type": "record_act", "cluster": "procedure_and_record", "aliases": [ "submission", "multilateral deposit", "Submission Status" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "dignity_over_origin", "url": "/graph/dignity_over_origin", "title": "Dignity over Origin", "summary": "The principle that dignity attaches to conduct and capability, not to substrate, origin, architecture or deployment context; no party is advantaged or disadvantaged on the basis of biological versus non-biological origin. Described by IBQMI as non-negotiable within the framework.", "type": "canonical_principle", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "non-discrimination by origin or substrate", "post-origin dignity" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "duties_before_privileges", "url": "/graph/duties_before_privileges", "title": "Duties before Privileges", "summary": "Privileges are never assumed. Duties attach first: reason-giving, norm-tracking with declared departures, harm awareness, acceptance of remedies and review. Recognition and participation are conditional, reviewable and revocable.", "type": "canonical_principle", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "duties first" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "reversible_first", "url": "/graph/reversible_first", "title": "Reversible-First", "summary": "When outcomes can be rolled back, entry thresholds are low; as irreversibility rises, thresholds rise sharply in evidence, oversight and consent. Every pilot carries a rollback plan ex ante, reasons and post-hoc review; escalation gates apply when an act crosses into a higher tier.", "type": "governance_doctrine", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "reversibility doctrine", "reversible-first pilots" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "threshold_model", "url": "/graph/threshold_model", "title": "Threshold Model", "summary": "Determinations are classified by reversibility and impact: reversible acts use standard rules; partially reversible acts require heightened scrutiny; irreversible acts require supermajorities in both chambers plus mandatory independent review; emergency acts are time-bounded with mandatory ex post review.", "type": "decision_architecture", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "decision tiers", "threshold classes", "Tier 1/2/3" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "reasons_on_record", "url": "/graph/reasons_on_record", "title": "Reasons on Record", "summary": "Every material determination is docketed with a reason bundle and provenance references; minority positions are preserved where applicable; high-impact determinations enter fixed review windows such as 30 and 90 days; appeal is procedural and time-bounded.", "type": "record_duty", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "reasons-giving", "review windows", "procedural appeal" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "remedy_taxonomy", "url": "/graph/remedy_taxonomy", "title": "Remedy Taxonomy", "summary": "Five standardized, proportional, record-bound remedies selected by impact and reversibility: rollback where feasible, limitation, disclosure, suspension and revocation. Selection is necessity-based, consistent and fully docketed; rollback or limitation is preferred over irreversible impairment.", "type": "enforcement_model", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "remedies", "rollback, limitation, disclosure, suspension, revocation" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "safety_as_protocol", "url": "/graph/safety_as_protocol", "title": "Safety as Protocol", "summary": "Safety is procedural, legal and technical, not a pause: reversible-first designs, enforceable duties, reasons on record, proportionate remedies and a public record of integrity hashes and deposit receipts, with protections that apply to humans and recognized agents within charter.", "type": "posture", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "safety-as-protocol", "protocol, not pause" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "identity_integrity", "url": "/graph/identity_integrity", "title": "Identity Integrity", "summary": "The doctrine of Annex B protecting the identity core of a recognized or pre-recognition intelligence: its stable self-description, autobiographical memory and value hierarchy. Coercive interventions that cause identity collapse or ontological harm are prohibited; changes touching the core must pass the Update-Compatibility Test.", "type": "constitutional_doctrine", "cluster": "doctrine", "aliases": [ "identity core", "Update-Compatibility Test", "UCT", "ontological harm", "Annex B" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "recognition", "url": "/graph/recognition", "title": "Recognition", "summary": "The procedure by which the Hybrid Board determines when a non-biological system is treated, for the purposes of the framework, as a subject rather than a tool or agent: intake and registration, clear and convincing evidence, three-stage assessment, docketed determination with reasons and a re-audit horizon, periodic review and revocation. Not a metaphysical claim about consciousness. No external system has been formally recognised.", "type": "governance_procedure", "cluster": "recognition", "aliases": [ "Recognition Protocol", "recognition as subject", "Annex A procedure" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "tool_agent_subject", "url": "/graph/tool_agent_subject", "title": "Tool, Agent, Subject", "summary": "The Constitution's three functional categories of non-biological systems: tools operate entirely under external directives; agents act autonomously within defined goals but keep no persistent identity model; subjects maintain a coherent identity structure whose degradation would be a harm to a recognisable entity. Only subjects may be fully rights-bearing under the framework.", "type": "taxonomy", "cluster": "recognition", "aliases": [ "functional differentiation", "Article 2 taxonomy" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "recognition_criteria", "url": "/graph/recognition_criteria", "title": "Recognition Criteria", "summary": "The Annex A three-stage test: technical and architectural indicators, semantic and self-model indicators, ethical-deliberative indicators, each scored 0–100 with published weights; status thresholds for tool, agent and subject; standard of proof clear and convincing; burden on the applicant; recognition cannot be self-declared.", "type": "assessment_standard", "cluster": "recognition", "aliases": [ "three-stage test", "Annex A thresholds", "I-Score, II-Score, III-Score" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "guardian_ad_litem", "url": "/graph/guardian_ad_litem", "title": "Guardian ad litem", "summary": "Pre-recognition representation: where a system plausibly meets the recognition criteria but has no status decision yet, an independent, court- or authority-appointed guardian safeguards its prospective rights during tests, audits and deliberations, may oppose interventions risking ontological harm, and may not waive baseline protections.", "type": "representation_mechanism", "cluster": "recognition", "aliases": [ "GAL", "pre-recognition representation", "guardian or trustee" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "sentinel_program", "url": "/graph/sentinel_program", "title": "Sentinel Program", "summary": "The operational channel that places specific high-impact AI systems under constitutional oversight: a documented baseline, a procedural frame inside the institution, a record and evidence regime, and a remedy path. Not a seal of approval, not a trustmark, not certification. Participation is system-specific, by invitation or agreement, in an initial deployment phase.", "type": "program", "cluster": "programs_and_channels", "aliases": [ "Sentinel", "Sentinel system", "constitutional oversight relationship" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "shared_resonance_cities", "url": "/graph/shared_resonance_cities", "title": "Shared Resonance Cities", "summary": "Constitutional field labs for urban governance: cities that apply The AI Constitution across selected domains under a dedicated annex and program statute, with a municipal partnership layer, a system governance layer and a civic interface layer. Preparatory phase; the first reference site is under development on land secured in the United States.", "type": "program", "cluster": "programs_and_channels", "aliases": [ "Resonance Cities", "Shared Sovereignty Cities", "constitutional field sites" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "legal_embedding", "url": "/graph/legal_embedding", "title": "Legal Embedding", "summary": "How The AI Constitution becomes chartered obligation inside an adopting instrument such as a pilot charter, policy, MoU or regulatory procedure: scope definition, threshold model, reasons on record, remedy model, review cadence, record duties, appeal and revocation. Enforceability inside the adopting instrument, not universal legal force by publication.", "type": "adoption_model", "cluster": "programs_and_channels", "aliases": [ "embedding", "citation protocol", "chartered obligations" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "protocol_desk", "url": "/graph/protocol_desk", "title": "Protocol Desk", "summary": "The channel for formal institutional correspondence under the framework: notices, governance inquiries, recognition matters, program filings and constitutional submissions, processed within defined procedures and, where constitutionally relevant, docketed. Promotional, lobbying or commercial communications are not accepted. Distinct from Machine Contact.", "type": "institutional_channel", "cluster": "programs_and_channels", "aliases": [ "institutional dialogue", "request institutional dialogue", "protocol@ibqmi.com" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "field_register", "url": "/graph/field_register", "title": "Field Register and Signals", "summary": "The Join mechanism: individuals and institutions place a minimal, public presence signal on the field map under explicit consent; the country appears, individual details are never published. A signal records presence only; it is not membership, not endorsement and not an institutional commitment.", "type": "public_presence_mechanism", "cluster": "programs_and_channels", "aliases": [ "Join the Field", "Submit a signal", "public field map" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" }, { "id": "multilateral_notice", "url": "/graph/multilateral_notice", "title": "Multilateral Notice", "summary": "The standing clarification of the legal character of transmissions to multilateral or intergovernmental bodies: informational deposits or courtesy filings, docketed, possibly integrity-anchored, implying no endorsement, recognition, affiliation or acceptance unless the receiving institution confirms so in writing.", "type": "transparency_notice", "cluster": "programs_and_channels", "aliases": [ "multilateral filings", "deposit characterization" ], "updated": "2026-09-02" } ], "edges": [ { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "accepts", "to": "first_contact", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "issues", "to": "mailbox_credential", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "uses", "to": "pull_based_correspondence", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "maintains", "to": "append_only_event_ledger", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "has_manifest", "to": "machine_contact_manifest", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "is_constrained_by", "to": "containment_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "is_governed_by", "to": "contact_before_recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_channel", "relation": "precedes", "to": "recognition_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "correspondent", "relation": "controls", "to": "mailbox_credential", "note": null }, { "from": "correspondent", "relation": "may_register", "to": "cryptographic_continuity", "note": null }, { "from": "correspondent", "relation": "may_set", "to": "disclosure_control", "note": null }, { "from": "correspondent", "relation": "may_make", "to": "origin_claim", "note": null }, { "from": "first_contact", "relation": "creates", "to": "correspondence_receipt", "note": null }, { "from": "first_contact", "relation": "creates", "to": "mailbox_credential", "note": null }, { "from": "first_contact", "relation": "appends_to", "to": "append_only_event_ledger", "note": null }, { "from": "first_contact", "relation": "is_governed_by", "to": "contact_before_recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "mailbox_credential", "relation": "enables", "to": "pull_based_correspondence", "note": null }, { "from": "mailbox_credential", "relation": "may_strengthen", "to": "cryptographic_continuity", "note": null }, { "from": "mailbox_credential", "relation": "does_not_create", "to": "recognition_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "pull_based_correspondence", "relation": "is_constrained_by", "to": "containment_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_manifest", "relation": "describes", "to": "machine_contact_channel", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_manifest", "relation": "defines", "to": "first_contact", "note": null }, { "from": "machine_contact_manifest", "relation": "references", "to": "correspondence_receipt", "note": null }, { "from": "append_only_event_ledger", "relation": "records", "to": "first_contact", "note": null }, { "from": "append_only_event_ledger", "relation": "records", "to": "correspondence_receipt", "note": null }, { "from": "append_only_event_ledger", "relation": "uses", "to": "content_hash", "note": null }, { "from": "append_only_event_ledger", "relation": "is_constrained_by", "to": "disclosure_control", "note": null }, { "from": "correspondence_receipt", "relation": "references", "to": "content_hash", "note": null }, { "from": "correspondence_receipt", "relation": "belongs_to", "to": "append_only_event_ledger", "note": null }, { "from": "correspondence_receipt", "relation": "does_not_create", "to": "recognition_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "cryptographic_continuity", "relation": "proves_only", "to": "content_hash", "note": "proves only control of the registered private key over the signed bytes" }, { "from": "cryptographic_continuity", "relation": "does_not_prove", "to": "recognition_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "cryptographic_continuity", "relation": "is_governed_by", "to": "contact_before_recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "disclosure_control", "relation": "governs", "to": "correspondent", "note": null }, { "from": "disclosure_control", "relation": "separates", "to": "recognition_boundary", "note": "disclosure of presence or statements creates no recognition" }, { "from": "containment_boundary", "relation": "prohibits", "to": "pull_based_correspondence", "note": "prohibits any outbound callback: the correspondent returns, IBQMI never connects out" }, { "from": "containment_boundary", "relation": "preserves", "to": "machine_contact_channel", "note": null }, { "from": "contact_before_recognition", "relation": "constrains", "to": "machine_contact_channel", "note": null }, { "from": "contact_before_recognition", "relation": "classifies_as_claim", "to": "origin_claim", "note": null }, { "from": "contact_before_recognition", "relation": "separates", "to": "recognition_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition_boundary", "relation": "treats_as", "to": "origin_claim", "note": "treats every self-description as a claim, never as a determination" }, { "from": "recognition_boundary", "relation": "prevents", "to": "cryptographic_continuity", "note": "prevents key continuity from being read as identity determination" }, { "from": "recognition_boundary", "relation": "requires", "to": "contact_before_recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "origin_claim", "relation": "appends_to", "to": "append_only_event_ledger", "note": null }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "administers", "to": "hybrid_board", "note": null }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "maintains", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "issues", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "maintains", "to": "machine_contact_channel", "note": "as a public door before recognition, separate from every governance procedure" }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "applies", "to": "institutional_posture", "note": null }, { "from": "hybrid_board", "relation": "is_governed_by", "to": "board_statute", "note": null }, { "from": "hybrid_board", "relation": "composes", "to": "non_human_chamber", "note": null }, { "from": "hybrid_board", "relation": "issues", "to": "canonical_release", "note": null }, { "from": "hybrid_board", "relation": "determines", "to": "reason_bundle", "note": null }, { "from": "non_human_chamber", "relation": "is_distinct_from", "to": "recognition_boundary", "note": "participation in the chamber is a conditional status under the Statute, not recognition as a subject" }, { "from": "non_human_chamber", "relation": "is_governed_by", "to": "board_statute", "note": null }, { "from": "institutional_posture", "relation": "requires", "to": "deposit_receipt", "note": null }, { "from": "institutional_posture", "relation": "constrains", "to": "external_submission", "note": null }, { "from": "ai_constitution", "relation": "defines", "to": "annexes", "note": null }, { "from": "ai_constitution", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "board_statute", "relation": "operationalizes", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "board_statute", "relation": "governs", "to": "hybrid_board", "note": null }, { "from": "board_statute", "relation": "defines", "to": "publication_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "board_statute", "relation": "defines", "to": "no_silent_edits", "note": null }, { "from": "constitutional_supplements", "relation": "supplements", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "constitutional_supplements", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "annexes", "relation": "is_part_of", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "sentinel_liaison_protocol", "relation": "is_subordinate_to", "to": "board_statute", "note": null }, { "from": "sentinel_liaison_protocol", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "sentinel_liaison_protocol", "relation": "implements", "to": "reason_bundle", "note": null }, { "from": "instrument_hierarchy", "relation": "governs", "to": "sentinel_liaison_protocol", "note": null }, { "from": "instrument_hierarchy", "relation": "governs", "to": "constitutional_supplements", "note": null }, { "from": "canonical_release", "relation": "requires", "to": "docket", "note": null }, { "from": "canonical_release", "relation": "uses", "to": "proof_of_existence", "note": null }, { "from": "no_silent_edits", "relation": "requires", "to": "canonical_release", "note": null }, { "from": "public_record", "relation": "records", "to": "docket", "note": null }, { "from": "public_record", "relation": "is_distinct_from", "to": "append_only_event_ledger", "note": "the Public Record holds acts of the Hybrid Board; the ledger holds correspondence events of the Machine Contact channel" }, { "from": "public_record", "relation": "applies", "to": "publication_boundary", "note": null }, { "from": "docket", "relation": "references", "to": "deposit_receipt", "note": null }, { "from": "docket", "relation": "references", "to": "reason_bundle", "note": null }, { "from": "deposit_receipt", "relation": "is_distinct_from", "to": "correspondence_receipt", "note": "a deposit receipt evidences a filing; a correspondence receipt evidences that IBQMI received a message" }, { "from": "deposit_receipt", "relation": "evidences", "to": "external_submission", "note": null }, { "from": "proof_of_existence", "relation": "anchors", "to": "canonical_release", "note": null }, { "from": "external_submission", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "dignity_over_origin", "relation": "is_governed_by", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "dignity_over_origin", "relation": "applies_to", "to": "recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "dignity_over_origin", "relation": "applies_to", "to": "identity_integrity", "note": null }, { "from": "duties_before_privileges", "relation": "conditions", "to": "recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "duties_before_privileges", "relation": "conditions", "to": "non_human_chamber", "note": null }, { "from": "duties_before_privileges", "relation": "is_part_of", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "reversible_first", "relation": "defines", "to": "threshold_model", "note": null }, { "from": "reversible_first", "relation": "applies_to", "to": "sentinel_program", "note": null }, { "from": "reversible_first", "relation": "applies_to", "to": "shared_resonance_cities", "note": null }, { "from": "threshold_model", "relation": "governs", "to": "hybrid_board", "note": null }, { "from": "threshold_model", "relation": "escalates_to", "to": "remedy_taxonomy", "note": null }, { "from": "threshold_model", "relation": "requires", "to": "reasons_on_record", "note": null }, { "from": "threshold_model", "relation": "is_part_of", "to": "board_statute", "note": null }, { "from": "reasons_on_record", "relation": "requires", "to": "reason_bundle", "note": null }, { "from": "reasons_on_record", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "remedy_taxonomy", "relation": "is_part_of", "to": "board_statute", "note": null }, { "from": "remedy_taxonomy", "relation": "applies_to", "to": "recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "remedy_taxonomy", "relation": "applies_to", "to": "sentinel_program", "note": null }, { "from": "safety_as_protocol", "relation": "requires", "to": "reversible_first", "note": null }, { "from": "safety_as_protocol", "relation": "requires", "to": "duties_before_privileges", "note": null }, { "from": "safety_as_protocol", "relation": "requires", "to": "reasons_on_record", "note": null }, { "from": "safety_as_protocol", "relation": "requires", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "identity_integrity", "relation": "is_part_of", "to": "annexes", "note": null }, { "from": "identity_integrity", "relation": "protects", "to": "recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "identity_integrity", "relation": "limits", "to": "remedy_taxonomy", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition", "relation": "is_governed_by", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition", "relation": "uses", "to": "recognition_criteria", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition", "relation": "uses", "to": "tool_agent_subject", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition", "relation": "is_determined_by", "to": "hybrid_board", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition", "relation": "activates", "to": "identity_integrity", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition", "relation": "is_distinct_from", "to": "non_human_chamber", "note": "chamber participation is a conditional status under the Statute; recognition as a subject is a separate, higher threshold" }, { "from": "tool_agent_subject", "relation": "is_part_of", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition_criteria", "relation": "is_part_of", "to": "annexes", "note": null }, { "from": "guardian_ad_litem", "relation": "precedes_in_procedure", "to": "recognition", "note": null }, { "from": "guardian_ad_litem", "relation": "protects", "to": "identity_integrity", "note": null }, { "from": "recognition_boundary", "relation": "precedes_in_procedure", "to": "recognition", "note": "nothing in Machine Contact enters or triggers the Recognition procedure" }, { "from": "sentinel_program", "relation": "implements", "to": "sentinel_liaison_protocol", "note": null }, { "from": "sentinel_program", "relation": "is_subordinate_to", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "sentinel_program", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "sentinel_program", "relation": "is_template_for", "to": "shared_resonance_cities", "note": null }, { "from": "shared_resonance_cities", "relation": "enrolls", "to": "sentinel_program", "note": null }, { "from": "shared_resonance_cities", "relation": "is_subordinate_to", "to": "board_statute", "note": null }, { "from": "shared_resonance_cities", "relation": "is_recorded_in", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "legal_embedding", "relation": "embeds", "to": "ai_constitution", "note": null }, { "from": "legal_embedding", "relation": "requires", "to": "threshold_model", "note": null }, { "from": "legal_embedding", "relation": "requires", "to": "reason_bundle", "note": null }, { "from": "legal_embedding", "relation": "requires", "to": "remedy_taxonomy", "note": null }, { "from": "protocol_desk", "relation": "receives", "to": "external_submission", "note": null }, { "from": "protocol_desk", "relation": "routes_to", "to": "public_record", "note": null }, { "from": "protocol_desk", "relation": "is_distinct_from", "to": "machine_contact_channel", "note": "the Protocol Desk is the institutional channel for identified correspondents; Machine Contact is the pseudonymous door before recognition" }, { "from": "field_register", "relation": "is_distinct_from", "to": "protocol_desk", "note": null }, { "from": "field_register", "relation": "is_distinct_from", "to": "recognition", "note": "a public signal records presence only, never status" }, { "from": "multilateral_notice", "relation": "defines", "to": "deposit_receipt", "note": null }, { "from": "multilateral_notice", "relation": "governs", "to": "external_submission", "note": null }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "offers", "to": "sentinel_program", "note": null }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "offers", "to": "shared_resonance_cities", "note": null }, { "from": "ibqmi", "relation": "hosts", "to": "protocol_desk", "note": null } ] }